Part B · Module 9
Quality of accounts
A share can look cheap because its profits are flattering, temporary or simply false. Before trusting a ratio, check that the figures behind it reflect economic reality. This module gives the checks that rule out most traps, the very ones the method applies systematically.
Before trusting a ratio, check that the figures are reliable. The main warning signs are profits poorly backed by cash, receivables and inventories growing faster than sales, shareholder dilution and profitability driven by debt. The module ends with a checklist to go through before buying.
- Measure the share of profit that is not collected in cash.
- Spot receivables and inventories growing abnormally.
- Measure dilution and understand its cost to the shareholder.
- Recognise accounting choices that flatter results.
- Have a checklist ready before any purchase.
1. Why doubt the accounts
Accounts are audited and follow standards. But these standards leave wide room for judgement: depreciation periods, the size of provisions, when a sale is recognised, whether a cost is classed as "exceptional". And management often has an interest in presenting steady, growing results: bonuses, the share price, compliance with bank covenants.
Outright fraud is rare. Most often it is window dressing: choices that are all legal, all pointing in the same direction. In small companies, little followed by analysts and sometimes audited by small firms, these practices go unnoticed more easily. That is also where discounts are most frequent: the two go together, which is why the checks below are essential.
White, Sondhi and Fried devote their whole book to this idea: financial statements are not reality, they are a representation of it built on choices. The analyst must restate the accounts to make them comparable and economically fair (chapter 2 for earnings quality, chapter 3 for the link between profit and cash, then one chapter per sensitive item: inventories, fixed assets, taxes, debt, pensions).
2. Profit not turned into cash
Module 8 showed that profit and cash must converge. The gap between the two, relative to the size of the company, is called accruals:
Share of profit not collected = (Net profit − Operating cash flow) / Average assets
Dumont Packaging: (6 − 8.5) / 108 = −2.3%. Negative: operating cash flow exceeds profit, which is healthy.
Take another fictitious company, Brillant Tech, whose profit is growing fast:
| €m | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net profit | 8 | 10 | 12 |
| Operating cash flow | 2 | 1 | −1 |
| Average assets | 70 | 80 | 90 |
| Share not collected | 8,6 % | 11,3 % | 14,4 % |
Profit rises, cash falls, the gap widens every year. Over three years, the company reported €30m of profit and collected €2m. Somewhere, assets are swelling (receivables, inventories, capitalised costs): these profits may never turn into money.
Richard Sloan (1996), cited by White, Sondhi and Fried, showed that companies whose profits rely most on these accounting gaps go on to see falling profits and lower stock returns, and vice versa. The market is impressed by reported profit and looks too little at its make-up: this is an exploitable anomaly, of the same kind as those in module 4.
3. Receivables and inventories growing too fast
Two simple indicators, to follow over several years:
Customer payment period (days) = Trade receivables / Revenue × 365 Dumont: 20 / 120 × 365 = 61 days Inventory turnover (days of revenue) = Inventories / Revenue × 365 Dumont: 18 / 120 × 365 = 55 days
The level depends on the sector; it is the trend that counts. When receivables grow much faster than sales, several explanations are possible:
- customers in difficulty, paying later and later or not at all;
- longer payment terms granted to support sales;
- sales booked too early, or even goods pushed onto distributors at year end (channel stuffing), which will come back as returns or discounts.
When inventories grow much faster than sales: products that sell poorly, a risk of obsolescence and future write-downs, or production costs held in stock so they do not weigh on profit.
A company can sell its receivables to a bank (factoring) to collect cash earlier. Its receivables fall and its operating cash flow rises, without any real improvement. The notes give the amounts sold: check them when the customer payment period suddenly drops.
4. Dilution
Each new share issued reduces every existing shareholder's share of future profits. Sources of dilution: capital increases, stock options and free shares for executives and employees, convertible bonds, acquisitions paid in shares.
Average annual dilution = (Shares at end / Shares at start)^(1 / number of years) − 1
Example. Brillant Tech went from 20 to 23 million shares in two years: (23 / 20)^(1/2) − 1 = 7.2% a year. If its total profit grows 10% a year, profit per share only grows about 2.6% a year. The shareholder has gained almost nothing from the reported growth.
Conversely, a company that buys back its shares at a good price increases the share of each remaining shareholder: it is a form of dividend, often more tax-efficient (module 3).
The method warns against companies that regularly raise capital on the back of a good story. Repeated dilution is how shareholders finance a company that does not generate its own money. For property companies, dilution is only a flaw if new units are issued below net asset value (module 13).
5. Returns boosted by debt, poorly covered interest
A high return on equity can come from a good business or simply from heavy borrowing. The so-called DuPont breakdown (module 11) shows this:
ROE = Net margin × Asset turnover × Leverage Leverage = Assets / Equity
An ROE of 20% with leverage of 2 comes from the business; the same ROE with leverage of 6 comes from debt, and will melt at the first slowdown.
Interest cover measures the safety margin against financial charges:
Interest cover = EBIT / Interest paid Dumont: 10 / 1 = 10
Below 3, the margin is thin; below 1.5, a modest fall in results can leave the company unable to pay its interest. Module 12 adds the Altman score.
6. Accounting choices that flatter
- Capitalising costs: recording development, software or launch costs as assets rather than expensing them. The year's profit rises; the charge comes later, as depreciation. Compare the amounts capitalised each year with total research spending.
- Lengthening depreciation periods: extending the useful life of machines from 8 to 12 years cuts the annual charge by a third. Changes in useful life are disclosed in the notes.
- Playing with provisions: provisioning heavily in a good year, then releasing those provisions in a bad year, to smooth results. Provision releases that regularly rescue profit are a warning sign.
- Recognising revenue early: long contracts accounted for by percentage of completion with optimistic estimates, sales with a right of return counted in full.
- Permanent "non-recurring" items: restructuring charges every year, excluded from the "underlying" profit highlighted by management (module 7).
None of these choices is illegal. But when several point the same way, reported profit overstates reality.
7. Acquisitions and goodwill
A company that grows through successive acquisitions presents specific difficulties:
- "organic" growth (like for like) is often much weaker than reported growth; the annual report usually gives it;
- goodwill builds up on the balance sheet; a sudden write-down reveals years later that an acquisition was overpaid;
- acquisitions appear under investing, not operations: operating cash flow stays fine even if all the money goes into takeovers (module 8).
Reasoning on tangible equity (module 6) neutralises part of this risk.
8. Qualitative signals
- The auditor: qualifications or emphasis paragraphs in the report, a change of auditor without explanation, a small firm for a company of significant size.
- Late publication: accounts published late, or postponed announcements, often precede bad news.
- Related parties: purchases, sales, rents or loans with companies owned by executives or the main shareholder. They can shift value out of the company, at the expense of minority shareholders.
- The controlling shareholder: a family or parent company holding the majority can decide on dividends, pay and transactions between group companies. Its track record in treating minority shareholders counts as much as the ratios.
- Off-balance-sheet commitments: guarantees given, purchase commitments, litigation, detailed in the notes.
- Share sales by executives: large, repeated sales by those who know the company best deserve attention; purchases rather inspire confidence.
9. A checklist before buying
- Is the profit of the last three to five years collected in cash (operating cash flow close to or above net profit)?
- Are receivables and inventories growing at the same pace as sales?
- Is the number of shares stable or falling?
- Is the year's profit inflated or depressed by non-recurring items?
- Does profitability come from the business or from debt? Is interest amply covered?
- Have there been changes in accounting method, depreciation periods or auditor?
- Does the auditor's report contain qualifications? Are the accounts published on time?
- What related-party transactions are there? Has the controlling shareholder treated minority shareholders well in the past?
An unfavourable answer does not necessarily rule out the company, but it demands a bigger discount or a convincing explanation. Several unfavourable answers at once: move on to the next one.
- Accounts leave a lot of room for judgement; the danger comes mainly from legal choices all pointing the same way.
- Share of profit not collected = (net profit − operating cash flow) / assets: above 10%, warning.
- Receivables and inventories growing much faster than sales often herald disappointments.
- Dilution reduces growth in earnings per share, the only growth that counts for the shareholder.
- High returns achieved with high leverage are fragile; interest cover below 1.5 is dangerous.
- Auditor, delays, related parties and controlling shareholder are checked in the annual report.
Exercises
Exercise 1: is the profit collected?
Net profit €15m, operating cash flow €3m, average assets €100m. The previous year: €12m, €10m, €90m. Calculate the share not collected for both years.
Answer. Previous year: (12 − 10) / 90 = 2.2%, normal. This year: (15 − 3) / 100 = 12%, above the 10% threshold. Profit rose 25% but cash collection collapsed: find out which balance sheet item swelled.
Exercise 2: customer payment period
Revenue of €80m then €88m; trade receivables of €13m then €20m. Calculate the customer payment period for both years.
Answer. 13 / 80 × 365 = 59 days, then 20 / 88 × 365 = 83 days. Sales grow 10%, receivables 54%: customers are paying three and a half weeks later. A signal to explain before any purchase.
Exercise 3: dilution
Net profit goes from €20m to €29m in three years, the number of shares from 40 to 50 million. Calculate annual profit growth, annual dilution and annual EPS growth.
Answer. Profit: (29 / 20)^(1/3) − 1 = 13.2% a year. Dilution: (50 / 40)^(1/3) − 1 = 7.7% a year. EPS: from €0.50 to €0.58, i.e. (0.58 / 0.50)^(1/3) − 1 = 5.1% a year. More than half of the reported growth was absorbed by dilution.
Exercise 4: leverage
Two companies have an ROE of 18%. A: net margin 9%, asset turnover 1, leverage 2. B: net margin 3%, turnover 1, leverage 6. Which is more fragile, and why?
Answer. B: its return comes from leverage (6 times more assets than equity). A 3-point fall in margin wipes out all its profit, while A would stay profitable. B probably also has weak interest cover.